Re: comments on PMP enhancements

John Hauser

I wrote:
As Jonathan Behrens has already noted, some systems depend on being
able to set mstatus.MXR = 1 temporarily to read S/U-executable
instructions, for emulation purposes. The proposal should be modified
to say that any S/U-mode-only PMP region that grants execute permission
to S/U modes (bit X is set), implicitly grants read permission to
M mode when MXR = 1.
Correction: I believe that should say "... implicitly grants read
permission to S/U modes when in M mode and MXR = 1". This is relevant
only when MPRV = 1 and MPP = 0 or 1, so it's a rather narrow case.
Hopefully I've got it right this time.

- John Hauser

Join to automatically receive all group messages.