If you have not seen these, they are a good

In general, these look like pretty good cleanups. I agree with Atish in his reviews where some consistency in the spec format would be nice. I'm not going to be pedantic about it, though, as long as

I think the current version should be in the title page but in a next line similar to platform spec. I think we should move this to a change log section to be in compatible with Platform

I think SBI specification should follow the same formatting as the platform spec. Here are few differences in generated pdf. 1. First page should contain the title and a version in next line

Reviewed-by: Atish Patra <atish.patra@...> -- Regards, Atish

This patch does following clean-ups in the entire asciidoc: 1. Ensure all lines don't extend beyond 80 characters 2. Have "Function: ", "Function Listing", and "Extension: " sub-sections under each

Add a simple makefile to build PDF and HTML documents using asciidoctor. These documents (PDF/HTML) are easy to read and can be shared/distributed. Signed-off-by: Anup Patel <anup.patel@...> ---

This series adds top-level makefile and does cleanups to generate PDF and HTML documents which are easy to read/navigate. Changes since v1: - Use RISC-V privilege style naming convention in PATCH2

Hi Jonathan, I don't feel strongly about this convention. I just wanted to have uniform convention for CSRs and registers name in SBI spec. Let me update this to use lowercase in next patch revision

Is there a reason that this convention was chosen? The privileged spec I think uses lowercase fixed-width text for CSRs. Jonathan

Hi All, PFA, generated PDF after applying this series. Regards, Anup

This patch does following clean-ups in the entire asciidoc: 1. Ensure all lines don't extend beyond 80 characters 2. Have "Function: ", "Function Listing", and "Extension: " sub-sections under each

Add a simple makefile to build PDF and HTML documents using asciidoctor. These documents (PDF/HTML) are easy to read and can be shared/distributed. Signed-off-by: Anup Patel <anup.patel@...> ---

This series adds top-level makefile and does cleanups to generate PDF and HTML documents which are easy to read/navigate. Anup Patel (2): Add a makefile to build usable documents Clean-up entire

On 11/16/20 1:28 AM, Anup Patel wrote: In an ideal world we could just reuse PSCI, but as we've discussed in recent meetings, the IP issues surrounding PSCI are unclear. So since

LGTM. Reviewed-by: Al Stone <ahs3@...> -- ciao, al ----------------------------------- Al Stone Software Engineer Red Hat, Inc. ahs3@... -----------------------------------

This patch adds SBI v0.2 compliant system reset extension. It defines the sbi_system_reset function which does different things based on reset_type parameter: 1. shutdown - Power-off the entire